Good Ginger Day to you. You can settle a ‘discussion’ I had with my oldest and most hormonal friend ( yeah, I went there, she’s pregnant, so logic and reason are… well, they’re the same as they always were actually) on romance. Apparently – as charged– I haven’t a romantic bone in my body, and as far as I can see she has no bones in her body at all and she’s being held together by whimsy.
Apparently some girl proposed to her boyfriend at some sporting event or other during the week. I didn’t see it, I care nothing at all about it, but both she and Ivan Yates seem determined to get some sort of response out of me.
‘Yeah,’ sez I, ‘Feckin’ eegit. Could you imagine if he’d said no?”
‘Oh COME ON!’ she said. ‘That’s so romantic!’
‘It’s cringe worthy.’
‘Oh right, I’d forgotten you’re too cool for school.’
‘I’m not, I just don’t find grande gestures romantic, it’s showboating of the highest order.’
‘It’s not, it’s sweet.’
‘If you say so. I’m not going to argue with you, you outweigh me by twenty pounds.’
‘Shut up you. Are you telling me that if the paramour got on his knees in front of a crowd of thousands and proposed you’d say ‘cringe’.’
‘I’d say, ‘Will you get up you feckin’ eegit!’ Hypothetically of course as it would never happen. He wouldn’t embarrass us that way.’
And it’s true, he wouldn’t. He’d know I’d hate it, and he doesn’t DO grande gestures. What he does do is act in a way that is beyond thoughtful and considerate and that’s far more romantic to me than walking in the rain or dropping to one knee in public.
Maybe Little Miss Bucket of Hormones – who confessed to WEEPING at an advert moments later– is correct, maybe I am unromantic. I couldn’t give a monkey’s about jewels, neither of us ever recall our anniversary, or any other significant dates in our time line. I don’t find red roses once a year romantic (I like it that he buys flowers regularly, for no particular reason other than he thinks I might like them). Seriously, there was nothing funnier to me than the panicked herd of men gathered around the flower section in Superquinn on Valentine’s day.
Meh, feh, bleh. Romance is the runt of the emotional litter; treat me well all year and I’ll return the favour. And if that makes me unromantic I shall wear my badge of sourpuss with pride.
So what say you? Are you romantic? Or do you wanna join me on the cynical bench of the too cool for schoolers? ( I’ve got the good coffee and the dry eyes)
( Leap Year, where grown ass women can make eegits of themselves because of an extra day in the calendar year, hurrah or something)
March 2, 2012 at 10:45 am |
Couldn’t agree more, I hate the cheesy so-called romantic gestures that actually don’t even reflect the state of the relationship once you dig below the surface a bit… especially when they happen on a “romanticommercially”-programmed day like Valentine’s Day. Now, at a sporting event, with a big crowd present? How romantic is that anyway? Just sounds like pressure on the other person to say yes so that both partners keep face. I like to be romantic, but in more subtle and meaningful ways. I think it’s a bit like charity, if you are too eager to show it off to the whole world and stage it, you’re probably doing it for the wrong reasons. But that’s just my opinion, and maybe that particular person had their heart in the right place and knew that her partner would be pleased to have such a proposal… hope so for the relationship!
March 2, 2012 at 10:48 am |
Hee, LIke this??
March 2, 2012 at 1:11 pm |
Har! Would probably have slapped him too.
March 2, 2012 at 10:53 am |
I would say that I am romantic, in that I enjoy things like my fiancée buying me flowers or something small because he thinks I would like it. However I hate Valentines Day or staying in hotels which promise you the perfect romantic evening, you just can’t buy romance.
It worries me when people try to justify their partner’s day to day bad behaviour with talking about how romantic they are on occasion. The first and foremost priority for me is whether they treat me well everyday.
March 2, 2012 at 11:17 am |
I planted some stuff as a romantic gesture, and up they come each year. Does that count?
Can’t bear romantic twaddle, though.
March 2, 2012 at 11:23 am |
Yersh, it does!
March 2, 2012 at 11:22 am |
Exactly, day-to-day treatment and behaviour VASTLY trumps the occasional gesture.
March 2, 2012 at 11:36 am |
Agreed, but then there’s folks with a very distinct idea of romance who would think the day-to-day cake is fine but where’s the delicious icing?
March 2, 2012 at 12:08 pm
See, I think Icing is sickly sweet and hard on the teeth.
March 2, 2012 at 11:27 am |
Lady, for all our disagreements we couldn’t be more in agreement on this. When I saw the Aviva proposal in the paper I went bright read. Even though I was sitting along I was mortified for the pair of them. The sheer horror of it. However, if they are bold over by romance and that made them happy well then good for them. Likewise , you are your worser half ain’t into that so you works for you both. I however am not so lucky. I equate romance with thoughtfulness and spontaneous gestures of devotion. Husband on the other hand is a walking manufactured hallmark sucker. Oh yes there are roses on v day, one year he had them delivered to my office. I locked myself in the toilet and cried with shame. In a male dominated work place it did not go down well. He did get down on one knee but thankfully we were alone and I just about managed to hold in my laugh. He also asked my dad could he marry me, jokingly my dad said, look son don’t make any
rash decisions I’m sure I can talk you out of it. Husband was livid. He writes me these epic little notes declaring his undying love, we go away every year for our anniversary. Every year. On that weekend. None of this makes me feel warm and fuzzy inside. Not least when he could easily bold me over but not dumping his laundry on the floor, cooking once in a while or even just throwing a tea bag in the bin as opposed to splattering it on the counter. Knowing that he had really thought about me would be far more romantic than expensive hallmark bollocks.
March 2, 2012 at 12:10 pm |
Agreed. The way to my heart is directly through my stomach: while he might not know his way around a washing machine, the man can sure cook.
March 2, 2012 at 7:30 pm |
I ain’t a bad cook so I could live with having to do that if he would just clean up after himself.
In other news, brought the cat to the vet. Turns out mammy knows best. Vet thinks it could be asthma or some other respiratory condition. We have a week of ab’s in the hope it’s just a virus. Husband said he missed everything after the vet said asthma, the pond signs clocking up in his head distracted him. Seriously though what a pain in the bollocks. I have a feeling this is going to be a nightmare. Financially and emotionally.
March 2, 2012 at 7:31 pm
*pound
March 2, 2012 at 8:27 pm |
Well, fingers crossed it’s just something simple like an infection and clears up.
March 2, 2012 at 1:51 pm |
My my theres a bunch of hard bitten realists around here today. Count me in too! I far prefer the mudane gestures that show I’m in his thoughts to some freaky public gesture in a crowd. If its about the two of you what do you need an audience for?
I’m also highly suspicious of repeated public declarations of undying love, I always think it sounds like they are trying to convince someone.
March 2, 2012 at 2:03 pm |
Oh(!) like Seal and Heidi and their wedding revow every year. Pfft.
I love this blog sometimes, I really do, it gives me the strangest notion that the world is right in sync after all.
March 2, 2012 at 3:47 pm |
I also find grand romantic gestures a pretty dull old cliche, and more than a little embarrassing. Public proposals make me wince. Yesterday, however, I teared up a bit watching a favorite baseball player’s retirement press conference. I MUST be hormonal. But…there we are.
March 2, 2012 at 8:04 pm |
Was that Tek Andraste? me too
March 2, 2012 at 8:29 pm |
Was he a terrific player? Stirred the memories? Worthy of the emotion? Then that’s good enough reason to be poignant.
March 3, 2012 at 9:56 am |
I don’t actually know anyone who WOULDN’T be embarrassed by that kind of shit.
Seems to me,the only reason to make such a private moment public would be if you were unsure of the answer and thought a bit of public embarrassment would sway the decision in your favour.
Myself..we drank half a bottle of absinthe,both decided to tie the knot,told everyone the next day and got married 3 months later.Would have got married the next week if it wasn’t for that darned,pesky law.
Romance,thou name art 70% liquor.
March 3, 2012 at 10:45 am |
Ha, that’s more like it. Terrific.